||Below expectation (0-2 points)
||Good (3-4 pts)
||Exceptional (5 pts)
||Made few substantive contributions during lab work and when completing assignments
||Contributed a “fair share” of substance during lab work and when completing assignments
||Contributed considerable substance during lab work and when completing assignments
||Rarely or never exercised leadership
||Accepted a “fair share” of leadership responsibilities
||Routinely provided excellent leadership
||Watches but does not contribute to discussions.
||Participated in group discussions. Freely shares ideas. Considers other people's feelings and ideas.
||Always active participant in group discussions. Shares many ideas related to completing assignments.
||Had a “take it or leave it” approach to completing assignments. Inflexible.
||Listens to others. Flexible when working with others.
||Encourages others to share their ideas. Listens attentively to others. Empathetic to other people's feelings and ideas.
||Disparaging; negative, withdrawn or belligerent; absent
||Positive; supportive; mostly constructive and upbeat
||Exceptionally positive and constructive; encourages other group members