UTCH2020: Interactions and Equity - Lewis

What Tests to Apply When Evaluating Sources

Authority

Authority

  • Is the author of the information named? 
  • What are the author's qualifications and expertise? 
  • Who sponsors the website?
  • Is the sponsor of the page reputable? How reputable?
  • Is there a link to information about the author and/or the sponsor and/or a way to contact them?
  • Are there links to any other organization(s) that supplies information to the website?
  • If the page includes neither a signature nor indicates a sponsor, is there a way to determine its origin?

Check for a header or footer showing affiliation.
Check the URL. http://www.fbi.gov
Check the domain. .edu, .com, .org, .net
Check for an "About Us" link.

Why is this important?

  • Anyone can publish anything on the web.
  • Qualifications can bolster confidence in the information presented.
  • Authorship and/or sponsorship can be an indication of bias or limited viewpoint.

Objectivity

Objectivity

  • Does the information show a minimum of bias? 
  • Is the page designed to sway opinion? 
  • Is the position clearly stated? 
  • Who sponsors the website?
  • Is the sponsor of the page reputable? 
  • How reputable? 
  • Is there any advertising on the page, and is it related to the information provided?

Why is this important?

Frequently the goals of the sponsors/authors are not clearly stated. 
Often the Web serves as a virtual soapbox expressing opinions not based in verifiable information.
The information provided by a commercial site can be "tailored" to highlight the product being sold in a favorable way, possibly leaving out important informationSponsorship can be an indication of bias or limited viewpoint.

Accuracy

Accuracy

  • Is there a way to verify that the information is reliable and error-free? 
  • Is there an editor or someone who verifies/checks the information?
  • Are sources of information cited and accurate?

Why is this important?

Information about the expertise of the author can lend credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Being able to go to cited sources also lends credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Even if there are no cited references, being able to verify information from a outside sources (journal articles, etc.) lends credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Remember! Unlike many traditional print resources, web resources rarely have editors, fact-checkers, peer reviewers.

 

 

 

Currency

Accuracy

  • Is there a way to verify that the information is reliable and error-free? 
  • Is there an editor or someone who verifies/checks the information?
  • Are sources of information cited and accurate?

Why is this important?

Information about the expertise of the author can lend credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Being able to go to cited sources also lends credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Even if there are no cited references, being able to verify information from a outside sources (journal articles, etc.) lends credibility to the accuracy of the information.
Remember! Unlike many traditional print resources, web resources rarely have editors, fact-checkers, peer reviewers.